Creamy Peanut Butter

9 reviews
Georgia Grinders Creamy Peanut Butter
9 reviews

Creamy Peanut Butter

Add to My List
Love it? Save your list! Close
Save all of your Hive favorites in one place! Log in Create an account
${ displayVariantPrice }

${ variantWeight } ${ variantWeightUnit } / ${ pricePerUnit }

The ultimate classic, this creamy peanut butter is as unpretentious as it gets, with just two ingredients. But the salty-smoky flavor and grainy-smooth texture of slow-roasted nuts is anything but simple.

Free shipping on orders $50+
Secure checkout

Already a subscriber? Sign in to your account

  • Gluten Free
  • Vegan

From PB&Js to peanut butter porters, creamy, melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter is an undeniable staple, thanks to its velvety texture and salty-sweet flavor. This slow-roasted, hand-crafted recipe folds around each scoop of your spoon, its speckled surface curling and cresting, for a familiar flavor that doesn’t need oil, sugar, or preservatives. Or jelly. Or bread. Or anything else.

Georgia Grinders is dedicated to cutting out environmentally impactful oils and forming personal relationships with their farmers.

The glass jar and metal lid are curbside recyclable once rinsed and separated. The plastic freshness seal can be sent to TerraCycle by following our special instructions.
These are general guidelines for broadly-recyclable materials. Check with your local recycler to confirm what they take.

Hive Five™ Certified

No need to guess what's in your food or how it was made. Our experts vet every product for ingredient integrity, responsible sourcing, and great taste using our own criteria called the Hive Five.

Learn More


ingredient integrity


low carbon footprint


recyclable packaging


committed to social good


rave worthy

How it does good

Committing to clean ingredients for people and planet

It’s hard to imagine a pantry without nut butter, but this simple snack isn’t always made with simplicity, or the environment, in mind. In fact, many nuts butters are made with palm oil, known for increasing deforestation and animal endangerment. Founded with cardiovascular health in mind, Georgia Grinders’ mission to use truly simple, high-quality ingredients also promotes environmental health by cutting out palm oil and paying attention to their farmers' sustainability practices. Being vertically integrated allows them to be present for each part of the production process, so they can provide handcrafted, small-batch nut butters, made cleanly. What they don’t get from the US, they source from Red River Foods, an international supplier dedicated to sustainable supply chains.

More Like This

About the Brand

Georgia Grinders

Georgia Grinders strives to create extraordinary nut butters from simple, all natural ingredients. Founder Jaime's grandfather began making his own nut butters in the 1970s to combat his predisposition to cardiovascular disease. Fast forward to today, all of Georgia Grinders' nut butters are crafted to honor his legacy of health, wellbeing, and clean eating. Their nut butters are crafted in small batches in a facility they own and operate in Atlanta, GA.

Shop Brand

How to use

Addicted to chocolate and peanut butter? Us too. Try spreading this on freshly baked brownies or, if you're feeling fancy, make a brownie batter sandwich around a peanut butter-flour spread, then bake.

What People Are Saying

Customer Reviews
4.6 Based on 9 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • peanut butter
  • Best
  • texture
  • Georgia
  • pantry
  • life
  • hands
  • taste
  • house
David B.
United States United States

It was good I like chunky better!!

Kathleen B.
United States United States

Just right

You improved peanut butter! Loved the flavor and texture.

United States United States

Creamy Peanut Butter

Great taste. Probably the best I've ever had. Too bad it's so expensive.

joseph h.
United States United States

Delicious foundation of life

A delicious foundation of life itself sounds like an over exaggeration but it is just the truth in our house. We love this peanut Butter and we buy multiples so that we are never with out. For over a year now there has never been a day when there wasn't a jar in the fridge! I would like to go to Georgia just to be able to shake their hands for giving us so much joy!

United States United States

Peanut butter

Nice - in my opinion it lacks a little salt - but it’s creamy and has enough oil!