Butterscotch Cookies

Eleni's Butterscotch Cookies

Butterscotch Cookies

Add to My List
${ total }

${ initialVariantWeight } ${ initialVariantWeightUnit } / ${ pricePerUnit }

Butterscotch cookies are a classic for a reason. Now you can revisit the taste you love with peanut-free and high-quality ingredients.
Free shipping on orders $65+
Secure checkout

Already a subscriber? Sign in to your account to add this to your existing Autoship box.


3.5 oz / $1.35 per oz

Butterscotch cookies are a classic for a reason. Now you can revisit the taste you love with peanut-free and high-quality ingredients.

This product is so popular, it just sold out.

We'll notify you when it’s back in stock.

Thanks! We will notify you when this product becomes available.

${ formError }

  • Kosher Supervision of America Certified

With a distinctive English flavor that takes us back to grandma's kitchen, Eleni's Butterscotch Cookies are a crowd-pleaser anywhere you go. Share them with friends, keep them to yourself, or eat them all in one sitting. Either way, grandma would be proud.

All Eleni’s cookies are Kosher certified and free of peanuts and tree nuts.
Wheat flour (niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), Butterscotch Chip (sugar hydrogenated palm kernel oil, skim milk powder, lactose [milk], buttermilk powder, whey powder [milk], coconut oil, color(s), soy lecithin, natural  flavor(s) and artificial  flavor(s), natural vanilla extract, salt), Unsalted Butter, Brown Sugar, Cane Sugar, Whole Eggs, Natural Flavor, Salt, Baking Soda.  Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Soy and Coconut.  


Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Soy and processed in a facility that handles coconut and sesame seeds.

View Nutrition Facts

The cardboard box is curbside recyclable. The plastic tray and wrapper are recyclable through TerraCycle by following our special instructions.
These are general guidelines for broadly-recyclable materials. Check with your local recycler to confirm what they take.

Hive Five™ Certified

No need to guess what's in your food or how it was made. Our experts vet every product for ingredient integrity, responsible sourcing, and great taste using our own criteria called the Hive Five.

Learn More


ingredient integrity


low carbon footprint


recyclable packaging


committed to social good


rave worthy

How it does good

No nuts, no problem

The perfect addition to all pantries, Eleni's line of crisp gourmet cookies is baked with the highest-quality, all-natural ingredients that are also entirely peanut and tree nut free. Eleni's doesn't just offer a nut-free flavor; they make sure the entire production process, start to finish, is free of any allergen. They believe parents shouldn't have to worry about allergies when bringing a snack into a home, school, or camp, so Eleni's creates sweet treats that everyone, peanut allergies or not, can enjoy.